(p. 51) "The woods became our savior." They both needed to support their families with their hunting and trapping skills and they relied upon one another to bring in enough game and foraged plants to provide for their houses. Here are Hunger Games: 20 Wild Revelations About Katniss And Gale's Relationship. (Or in choosing to be with either of them, choosing to be with a guy focused on his own needs over hers based on Gale and Peeta's discussion over who Katniss will "choose" and on how they each engage with Katniss). Haymitch, however, can tell that while Peeta is madly in love, Katniss isn't. Let's go over all the times he failed to show friendship to her. While Peeta fell for the girl who sang like a bird on the first day of school, he never got to know her like her best friend Gale did. She still doesn't realize that Peeta isn't acting. In The Hunger Games, how does Katniss overcome her situation? It'd make more sense if Katniss went with her bestfriend, right? I mean, I'm not in the position to do so but I can't help feeling angry about the love triangle. eNotes.com will help you with any book or any question. Katniss finds that her door has been locked from the outside; she is again the Capitol's prisoner. I think there is something to the argument of Peeta coming to see Katniss as she really is vs getting to see Katniss as other than he thought she was and so when I re-read the books I will definitely look to see for which one strikes me as more supported by the text. They kiss in front of the audience and continue to kiss even as Caesar Flickerman tries to get them to stop. Katniss was an extremely unstable girl, intelligent and resourceful, but none-the-less unstable. The implied message here is that Katniss should do for Peeta what he would do for her, but after Katniss saves Peeta, she does not do this. But if we follow the premise of the book, arguably, if she had never met Peeta, she would have gone hungry as he would not have been there to throw her the bread that helped her and her family to survive during a time when there were no resources and Katniss was ready to give up on life. Katniss cares for Gale, and she risks punishment and her life to stop him from continuing to be whipped. The silent communication between Katniss and Gale is impressive throughout the series, particularly in the final book and film. Detailed explanations, analysis, and citation info for every important quote on LitCharts. Haymitch claims that Katniss is "punishing [Peeta] over and over for things that are out of his control," but when looked at closely, is that really what Katniss is doing? What is hinted at in this first chapter is that Gale's feelings for Katniss go beyond friendship rather than just being platonic. I do not make the argument that Peeta was dishonest about himself. Katniss and Gale had a lot of history before Peeta ever really came into the picture in The Hunger Games. Answered by jill d #170087 3 years ago 8/21/2020 1:42 PM. Maybe it's too painful for him to visit the person he thought he'd marry someday. Not only that but every characters actions had consequences, especially Katniss, who more than anyone made mistake after mistake. Both of the teens change their minds about running away at different points in the series, but Gale's instinct to put Katniss, along with his family, over any sense of duty or rebellion that he feels points toward his commitment to the girl from the Seam. In the end, fighting the Capitol did result in the loss of her sister and thousands of other citizens, but it did end the fascist regime that controlled Panem and, hopefully, resulted in the freedom for everyone in the country. Question: If Katniss never met Peeta, how do you think her life be? This is incorrect. Katniss spends the rest of the day crying on her bed. Summary and Analysis Deadly. They have also written several books. And Gale is devoted to his family. Their writing has been featured in numerous magazines, literary journals, digital projects, educational media, websites, nonprofit materials and marketing campaigns. Not shutting me out, abandoning me, greeting me with hostility at every turn." Question: Do you really think that Peeta was purposefully manipulating Katniss, or that he was really in love with her? He is both a physical danger and a psychological influence on her on top of trying to kill her; he lowers her mental health by causing her to make decisions and judgments based on the guilt she feels instead of what she wants and needs and by making her feel lower than she already feels at various parts in Mockingjay. Gale and Katniss get along and understand each other, but Gale is more vocal and angry than Katniss in his opposition to the way in which they live. It was fine until you know, Gale and the Prim thing. Katniss does fall in love with Peeta, who is also in love with her. In particular, you might want to focus on the first chapter and the response of . Gale and Katniss are therefore childhood friends who have learnt to survive in a grim world and are the providers for their families. The closest Katniss comes to assessing Gale and Peeta and assessing if they are viable partners, is wondering if she has feelings for them, what those feelings mean, realizing that she does have feelings for Peeta, etc. Removing #book# They kiss in front of the audience and continue to kiss even as Caesar Flickerman tries to get them to stop. Knowing that he had to care for not only his family but Katniss's while she was in the Games is probably the only thing that kept him from volunteering as tribute. While he is not necessarily Katniss' confidant, Katniss can be herself with Gale and has fewer reservations about him than she does with others. While most of the passionate moments in the series belong to Katniss and Peeta, there's no denying the physical chemistry between Katniss and her best friend, Gale. I think she would have wanted to stay friends with Gale. So far, she has been able to avoid addressing her conflicting feelings because of the Hunger Games, but now she will have to tackle them head-on. Gale is the only person close to Katniss who really challenges her and calls her out on her lies, which is the mark of a good partner. "Neither Gale nor Peeta are a true match for Katniss, although Katniss is an acceptable match for either of them. In Mockingjay, Katniss is drawn towards both Peeta and Gale at points in the story, but the writing for the moments with Gale are weaker than the moments written with Peeta. This is something their relationship would never really recover from. After Katniss was sent back to District 12 following her trial for the assassination of Alma Coin, not only did she never truly say goodbye to Gale, but she didn't even converse with Peeta until she saw him back at home. Peeta's view of life is easier to reconcile to Katniss' view of life and in this regard is also beneficial and balancing as Peeta (and his perspectives) gives Katniss hope. She doesn't care nearly as much about herself as she does for them. Teacher Editions with classroom activities for all 1766 titles we cover. -Katniss, Catching Fire. She wanted a flawed character that we could relate to on a complex level. Peeta is sweet, sensitive, smooth-talking, and steadfast. Recalling the words to the song that Katniss sings for a propaganda shoot with Cressida and her film crew during Mockingjay, Gale tears up when he says that he feels as if he is the man in the song, who will forever be waiting for Katniss's answer. Our summaries and analyses are written by experts, and your questions are answered by real teachers. Nalini Marquez (author) on February 05, 2014: I borrowed, read, and returned the books a few months ago and wrote my analyses of The Hunger Games from what I remembered from the books and from what I have seen in the movies and that is why I did not include cited text evidence to substantiate my claims. It's a bit of a melodramatic moment, particularly in the middle of a war, but it's also understandable that Gale wants an answer when it's plain that any moment could be his last-- not to mention that he's a teenager with strong emotions. While her feelings seem to point toward Peeta, there's no denying that she seems jealous over Gale kissing someone else in District 2, or that they made a better fighting and hunting team than she and Peeta did. Although Gale and Katniss don't always agree on how the rebellion should be fought, Gale supports Katniss when she acts as the Mockingjay. Peeta, whose life was far from perfect but didn't live in the Seam, doesn't share Gale's understanding. Katniss' feelings towards Gale and Peeta are complicated, but her feelings are complicated in general because of everything she has been through and who she is as a person. They know that Katniss' feistiness will attract viewers, so they reward her for this. He loved Prim like his own siblings. He's not the prime reason she and her family survived, but he definitely helped her learn several of the hunting tips and tricks that she uses on a daily basis that helped her win the Hunger Games. It's also important to note, as ever, that these two are teenagers faced with daily violence and a revolution. But I won't have that luxury for who knows how long." Katniss's mother Character Analysis in Catching Fire | LitCharts On the rooftop the night before the first Games, he specifically says he doesnt want the Capital to change him. She plays up her affection for Peeta on-stage, kissing him and snuggling up against him. By the end of the series, we see Katniss and Peeta grow together, grow separately, and ultimately end up back together. Katniss' spirit, view of life, and what she wants do not align with Gale and Peeta. Or because of how it would be viewed back in District 12. In the 4000-word article I used manipulation a total of 6 times, 1 of which was an inclusion of a quote from the text. Peeta was nothing if not a kind loving boy who cared deeply for Katniss. When I re-read the books I will look for this part to add it as support to my hub or I will take that part out if there is not the support for it that I remember there to be. Katniss has trouble reconciling this reality up until the very end, in which she still hopes to find Gale and rekindle the romance in their former meeting place in the woods. Mockingjay - Does Katniss truly love Peeta or just need him to "survive Gale is active, angry at the Capitol, outspoken, action-taking, and wants to fight for the future that could be. To be fair, all of the Districts in Panem, aside from the rich ones, have impoverished conditions, too. Following her father's death, her mother fell into deep depression and now rarely speaks. It was so hard to get through and I didn't understand what you were trying to say throughout practically the entire piece. Indeed, Katniss and Peeta's relationship in The Hunger Games is a complex love that was born from trauma, grief, mutual comfort, and understanding. Her reservations don't come from wanting to be with Gale, but a fear of what Gale will think. They move in rhythm with each other, knowing one another's goals without ever having to speak them, whether it's regarding a formation or what to do if one of them gets captured. Being in love with a person and/or caring for a person doesn't mean that a manipulative person will stop being a manipulative person and/or that he/she will not manipulate those that he/she cares about. The original text plus a side-by-side modern translation of. For example: "Both Gale and Peeta want Katniss but neither one of them take into account what Katniss wants and most of the time Katniss does not even get to take into account what she wants because what she wants (and what little she knows that she wants) is constantly manipulated and threatened by forces outside of her control and by the people in her life.". She longs for him in her mind, but she is also resistant to being left with him and/or is resistant to having to handle him, especially since the person that she longs for no longer knows her and no longer exists. Start your 48-hour free trial to get access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts. The fact that Gale's heartless war plan was possibly used in the harrowing moment of Mockingjay that resulted in the loss of Primrose Everdeen was likely the major deciding factor. It isn't how he would be treating me at all. Choosing to pursue her feelings for Gale means taking on a role in a cause that she does not necessarily believe in and/or want to be a part of in order to be with the person she cares for. Now that they're outside the Games, Katniss and Peeta both are searching for the truth. Katniss is an acceptable match for Gale and Peeta because both Gale and Peeta have seen or come to see Katniss for who and what she is and have found traits that they want in a partner and are more than happy to take Katniss as she is.". Refine any search. Regardless of who Katniss chose, if she were written to make a choice, Katniss would have had to compromise some aspect of herself by choosing Gale or Peeta, and she would have had to reconcile her choice to be with that partner along with her view of life and the future, as well as with the way in which either Gale or Peeta affected or influenced her. The original text plus a side-by-side modern translation of. Author Suzanne Collins gave readers plenty of reasons why Katniss and Peeta also work well together, and they do develop a chemistry together that feels stronger than any feelings between Katniss and Gale. She thinks about Gale and knows that she's going to have to face him as well as Peeta once she's a "safe" distance from the Capitol. Peeta is someone that she cares for but who she has a complicated dynamic with. The fact that Gale Hawthorne is the only person who can refer to Katniss Everdeen as "Catnip," his special nickname for the young woman, is reminiscent of so many other great love stories, while Peeta Mellark's lack of nickname for Katniss is just further evidence that he doesn't know her as well as Gale does. He would be trying to get me back at any cost. She comes to love him, and she does need him. She is fiercely protective of her family and practical, having learned to care for her mom and little sister, Prim, after their father died in a mining accident when Katniss was just eleven. Not here with every eye upon me. When the train stops for fuel, Katniss walks with Peeta out along the tracks, past the end of the train, and he learns that Katniss doesn't know how she feels about him, how she has done and said a lot of things in order to keep both of them alive and has not acted out of love like he has. From the creators of SparkNotes, something better. And theres also the fact that she thinks this in a moment when Peeta was being awful to her and she was feeling low, and that we tend to think of ourselves and of things as worse than we/they really are when people are being awful to us and when we are feeling low. Katniss continues to discover that shes made more connections in District 12 than she realized. His hatred for the Capitol is fueled by a rage that seems to surpass that of any other citizen. This is not so much something Katniss wants so much as a compromise that Katniss is willing to make in order to be with Gale.". Haymitch's comment reflects Katniss' treatment of Peeta after he tried to kill her but also shows the expectations of how Katniss is expected to behave towards Peeta. Could she choose to set boundaries with those around her and stop letting people manipulate her? Being with Gale requires her to change, and while Katniss cannot revert to her former self, she still has to change to a self-other than what she is. Answer: Katniss' journey and who she met was deliberate and designed by Suzanne Collins. with Gale in the story as written. --Katniss, Chapter 26, The Hunger Games. When Katniss tells Gale that she feels wrong kissing Peeta because of him, for example, Gale scoffs that he wishes he could believe her words. That kind of love is solid and undeniable and can weave together with romantic love when they both want it and need it and feel it. You present Katniss as a victim time and time again, but I think that completely misses the entire point of the story. It is only when Katniss is on her way home, when she changes out of her dress and removes her make-up removing some of the masks that she has put on for the Capitol that she begins to feel like herself again. Dude, this was so difficult to read. It ended up being the very plan that resulted in the loss of Primrose Everdeen, the little duck whom Katniss volunteered for in the first place. The promise that life can go on, no matter how bad our losses. He may have been jealous of her, but his apology to her during the train ride to 11 during the victory tour speaks for itself. The Hunger Games Suzanne Collins Study Guide Mastery Quizzes Flashcards Symbols Questions & Answers What happened to Katniss's father and mother? "My students can't get enough of your charts and their results have gone through the roof." Katniss has never had enough running water to take a shower, and if she had wanted hot water in District 12, she would have had to boil it herself. Evidence that Gale and Peeta have come to see Katniss as she is? Much of her survival through her first Games also depended on Rue, whom she befriended during the Games. She places their safety above her own and finds relief in the knowledge that they will be safe. Who does Katniss love? | The Hunger Games Questions | Q & A Katnisss, Katniss walks downstairs, where she finds her, though hes too weak to leave Katnisss house. that served him and that did not serve Katniss or that did not give Katniss the space to make the decisions that she would want to make or have the responses that she would want to have without having guilt, pressure, judgment, etc. -Mockingjay. Sara has been writing professionally for 26 years. Remember the scene when Gale stayed to save Prim (when there's some bombing thing and everyone is forced to go deeper into the underground)? As they roll into the District 12 station and Peeta takes her hand, it's as if it's for the last time. It looks forced. I think Katniss is an amazing character. She understands that Gale is more than a friend to her but can't admit that she has romantic feelings toward him. Nalini Marquez (author) on April 29, 2020: Thank you for your feedback and your perspective. He works hard to keep the two of them separate, probably so that Katniss won't say anything to Peeta about her conflicted feelings, which would destroy the one thing that is preventing the Capitol from killing them: their mad love for one another. What are some quotes to suggest that The Hunger Games is dystopian? They finish the night at the Victory Banquet, Katniss never letting go of Peeta's hand, and then return to their rooms for the night. Peeta is from District 12, but he is part of a slightly "higher class" or higher group in District 12. When they're ready, Katniss and Peeta sit together on the small sofa, Katniss tucking her . Rather, it shows how important her friends are to her. They also demonstrate how advanced technology must be in the Capitol, since they can genetically alter animals. Katniss still grieves for the loss of her father from working in these same mines, so discovering that Gale now has the same job has to be hard for her, whether she's in love with him or not. Its latest criticized incarnation is of the love triangle between Katniss Everdeen, Peeta Mellark, and Gale Hawthorne. Although Gale and Katniss have never acknowledged how close they are before, the fact that they now have limited time together pushes them to drop some of their pretenseswhich is why Katniss doesnt hesitate to embrace Gale when he enters the room. Katniss explains that she left without letting them say anything, then she asks if they'll go after her family or arrest her. What are ten words that describe Katniss in The Hunger Games. Hunger Games: 20 Wild Revelations About Katniss And Gale's Relationship Peeta answers that he doesn't think the Gamemakers paid much attention to him, that he just threw around a few heavy objects and then they said he could go. What quotes show conflict in the book The Hunger Games? The only time Gale cries is over Katniss, which supports his deep feelings for the Girl on Fire. "My students can't get enough of your charts and their results have gone through the roof." Educators go through a rigorous application process, and every answer they submit is reviewed by our in-house editorial team. Find related themes, quotes, symbols, characters, and more. A lot of claims, but you need evidence from the book to substantiate them. Why is Gale's name in the reaping forty-two times? We only witness Gale cry once throughout the series, and it's not following the demise of Primrose Everdeen, the loss of District 12 or even when getting hurt in battle. While they are living in District 13, Katniss and Gale are rarely seen apart, as Gale understands that Katniss needs a friend to be by her side. Katniss is of course responsible for looking after Prim and her mother, as her desire to protect Prim from as much as possible indicates. What I did as part of the Games. The Katniss at the beginning of the story might have eventually had a future with Gale but that Katniss exists primarily as a contrast and memory to the Katniss she becomes and that Katniss ending up with Gale would have been a years-down-the-line Katniss that would still likely have a different worldview than Gale and that we wouldn't have gotten to read and that there might have been no story to. In the third book, Katniss considers being active in the rebellion in a way that she thinks will be agreeable to Gale. Katniss Everdeen Character Analysis in The Hunger Games | SparkNotes As TruthTrek said, she was meant to be a flawed character. He is perfect for her, because I think that Gale is too much like her, and she has enough hatred in her for both her and Gale. The analysis in this article was an analysis of the love triangle between Katniss, Gale, and Peeta and of the relationships as they compared with each other and their effects on and relation to Katniss, and as written, supports this information and argument. That night, Peeta goes to his room and Katniss doesn't see him again until they've pulled into the District 12 station. Katniss Everdeen The protagonist of the novel and its narrator, Katniss Everdeen is a strong, resourceful sixteen-year-old who is far more mature than her age would suggest. Let's make Gale kill Prim. Does Katniss ever love Gale the way he wants her to in The Hunger Games? Imagine for a second Gale had died while she was gone, or just wasnt in the story period. She second-guesses everything that he does and understands, too, that her survival depends upon her killing him and that his survival depends upon him killing her, a dynamic that is in direct contrast with her partnership with Gale. from your Reading List will also remove any from Peeta or from others. But interestingly enough, the question you bring up as it relates to Peeta could be argued that he never truly does come to see her as she as, but rather just gets to see her as other than what he thought she was. With everything thats at stake and with everything they have been through, they still are able to see Katniss as she is and as she is at that point in time (or how they perceive her to be and to be at that point in time), and have determined that she is an acceptable partner. It's too complicated. Refine any search. The MAIN reason I wanted to write this review is that it is so poorly written!!! I think Collins makes it clear that she admires Peeta and wants what he gives her. Distrustful. Plutarch Heavensbee knows that the people wouldn't follow Gale into battle as ardently as they would a lovesick 16-year-old girl who not only survived the Hunger Games but sacrificed herself to save her little sister as well as her boyfriend. Gale Hawthorne's views are fundamentally different, as he argues from a more traditional standpoint where casualties of war are acceptable as long as they help win it. She is a hunter and a survivor. What about his family that he worked so hard to protect? I love how self sacrificing she is especially for the people she loves. Jennifer Lawrence is known for her humor and practical jokes, so it shouldn't surprise any fan to learn that she sabotaged all of her kisses with Gale on purpose. The Hunger Games could have had an entirely different ending had Gale opted to volunteer in place of Peeta. Haymitch explains that the Gamemakers must have liked her temper. As opposed to what I did out of anger at the Capitol. and by the people in her life (Gale, Peeta, Haymitch, President Coin, etc.). Complete your free account to request a guide. These are questions to be unraveled back home, in the peace and quiet of the woods, when no one is watching. Peeta stands as a foil to Gale since he is the hunting partner that Katniss cannot trust. However, that is a project I have for later this year when I re-read the books. I have chosen Gale" (Mockingjay). She tries to remember who she is. But she has developed feelings for Peeta and a need for him, as the beginning of her statement was, "I wish Peeta were here to hold me, until I remember I'm not supposed to wish that anymore. "A future with Peeta is the Capitol's design, not mine.". Would she even be alive? Katniss finds the discussion challenging, but Caesar helps her, saying that he knew that she was in love with Peeta for the first time when she called out his name after hearing about the rule change. Dec 29, 2022 11:31 AM EST Katniss Everdeen Hunting in the Woods outside District Twelve. Yes. I'll admit that I'm Gale and Katniss shipper and I'd have accepted it better if Katniss decides to go with Peeta without the whole bomb thing. Gale and Peeta want Katniss but do not take Katniss or what Katniss wants into account. When he gets to know the real Katniss, or when he gets to see her other than as he thought she was, he gets to see her as she is. Katniss Everdeen Character Analysis. Peeta comes to be a better match for Katniss than Gale, primarily because Katniss comes to "need" Peeta, and Peeta brings to Katniss' life things she does not bring herself. Creating notes and highlights requires a free LitCharts account. It is clear, too, that the Gamemakers assign scores based on the entertainment value that each player can bring to the Games.

The Apartments At The Sycamores, Articles W